Introduction
While the smooth baritone of Alan Jackson might usually paint a picture of small-town romance and enduring love, his cover of “She Just Started Liking Cheatin’ Songs” takes a subtler turn. Originally written by Kent Robbins, the song found its first life on John Anderson’s 1980 album of the same name.
Jackson, known for his keen eye for relatable storytelling, brought the song to a new audience with his 1999 album “Under the Influence.” Though not released as a single, “She Just Started Liking Cheatin’ Songs” gained traction through unsolicited airplay, a testament to its intriguing narrative.
The song plays on a man’s growing suspicion. His partner, always one for love songs and happy melodies, has developed a fondness for tunes about betrayal. Lines like “I wonder if she’s seeing somebody new” and “I can’t blame a body lookin'” hint at a blossoming insecurity. Is it the lyrics themselves that intrigue her, or is the thematic shift a subtle cry for help or a veiled confession?
Jackson’s version masterfully captures this internal conflict. The melody remains light and catchy, mirroring the surface harmony of the relationship. Yet, the lyrics plant seeds of doubt, leaving the listener to wonder if this is a harmless change in taste or a sign of deeper trouble brewing beneath the surface. As the final verse ponders, “Is she too started likin’ cheatin’ songs?,” we’re left without a clear answer, just the lingering unease of a love story taking an unexpected turn.